I wanted to buy a 2 bed house (£65k) in 2000, but because of being on a lowish wage at the time, couldn't. By 2003 and after being promoted etc I was earning more than enough to buy the same house (£74kish) if HPI had run at 3 or 4% yoy.
But the same house now is £140+k and I'm still on a basically the same wage after inflation.
If there was a HPC of 50% tomorrow then that still means I'm at least 4-5 years behind on mortgage payments compared to if I had been able to buy in 2003.
The point I'm getting to is that it means 4-5 years more full-time work, no semi retirement working p/t at B&Q and no chance of early retirement.
If the government did engineer HPI and it could be proved, and in doing so means that people have to work later in life (remember this is your time, and you only get it once) there could be a case for compensation.
What do you reckon?