Ah-so Posted February 11, 2015 Share Posted February 11, 2015 I did actually ask someone from the Revenue once why, given so many transactions are electronic, why there is not some sort of automated accounting for vat that doesn't rely on declaring it. They basically admitted it's designed to be elastic and blurred at the edges. Presumably it's preferable a blind eye is turned, to some sort of fiddle, in lean times if it keeps a dozen, of the firm's employees, in jobs and off welfare.VAT is pretty complex when you get to accounting for it. An add-on at the till would make things easier to calculate in retail. It is pretty difficult to calculate for big businesses though. I doubt that the reason is because of the need to create work for tax officials. Sounds like an office joke. The current system does not stop people putting undeclared stock on the shelves and not running the sale through the till. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Lewis Gordon Pugh Posted February 11, 2015 Share Posted February 11, 2015 That's because of Swiss data protection and privacy laws. As for this story - its fairly obvious that the middle class become corporate lawyers and accountants to help the ruling class hide the fact they don't operate on the same rules as the pretend democracy we live in.The "value add" of accountants and lawyers isn't some rare intelligence found through years of learning - its a complex system built over time to given them just enough to keep them happy whilst obfuscating the reality of where this idea of "money" and "debt" comes from. Its all a big game to keep people working and using up their lives rather than focussing on being "equal" - the aim of all this is ultimately power. Banks are the same - why do we even both complaining. Its not going to change. Even the nobles had to threaten the monarchy with imprisonment and death to get them to sign the magna carta - no one relinquishes power without a fight. The masses don't care, the religious turn to faith, the few people who are aware simply waste their entire lives pointing out the facts to people who aren't interested. Syrian or Iraqi leaders being deposed is nothing to do with humanitarian efforts - its to stop Russia gaining complete control of gas supplies in Europe. The drop in oil price is not some magical market miracle its an effort to stop Russian power (and bankrupt the shale gas fields in USA). The rise in the franc was basically to prevent huge capital flows into Switzerland prior to Euro devaluation through QE. Remember when you have a monopoly you flex prices to prevent competition - because long term all you care about is always owning the market, because then you can set your own price. We're just serfs trying to make a living... Best thing I have read in weeks. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SNACR Posted February 11, 2015 Share Posted February 11, 2015 VAT is pretty complex when you get to accounting for it. An add-on at the till would make things easier to calculate in retail. It is pretty difficult to calculate for big businesses though. I doubt that the reason is because of the need to create work for tax officials. Sounds like an office joke. The current system does not stop people putting undeclared stock on the shelves and not running the sale through the till. You misunderstand it is to allow the taxpayer to stay in business in lean times ergo keeping the employees of the business in their jobs. They were being serious. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
interestrateripoff Posted February 12, 2015 Share Posted February 12, 2015 UK may follow U.S. lead if pursues HSBC over tax- British authorities may follow a trail set by their U.S. counterparts in investigating allegations that HSBC's Swiss private bank helped its customers dodge taxes, lawyers say. Wonderful we can't do anything without holding America's hand. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gf3 Posted February 12, 2015 Share Posted February 12, 2015 One down 6 to go Barclays Bank (Suisse) SA, Geneva Barclays Capital, Zurich Branch of Barclays Bank PLC, London Lloyds Bank plc, Londres, succursale de Genève, Geneva HSBC Private Bank (Suisse) SA, Geneva IG Bank S.A., Geneva RBS Coutts Bank AG Standard Chartered Bank (Switzerland) SA Then we just have to work through this lot. List of tax havens and countries of financial secrecyThe list includes the Financial Secrecy Index (FSI) according to Tax Justice Network. The higher FSI, the larger influence on world economy in terms of economical secrecy or tax avoidance. 1. Switzerland (FSI 1765,2) 2. Luxembourg (FSI 1454,4) 3. Hong Kong (FSI 1283,4) 4. Cayman Islands (FSI 1233,5) 5. Singapore (FSI 1216,8) 6. United States(Mainland) (FSI 1212,9) 7. Lebanon (FSI 747,8) 8. Germany (FSI 738,3) 9. Jersey (FSI 591,2) 10. Japan (FSI 513,1) 11. Panama (FSI 489,6) 12. Malaysia (Labuan) (FSI 471,6) 13. Bahrain (FSI 461,1) 14. Bermuda (FSI 432,3) 15. Guernsey (FSI 419,3) 16. United Arab Emirates (Dubai) (FSI 419,0) 17. Canada (FSI 418,5) 18. Austria (FSI 400,8) 19. Mauritius (FSI 397,8) 20. British Virgin Islands (FSI 385,4) 21. United Kingdom(Mainland) (FSI 361,3) 22. Macao (FSI 360,4) 23. Marshall Islands (FSI 329,6) 24. South Korea (FSI 328,7) 25. Russia (FSI 325,2) 26. Barbados (FSI 317,4) 27. Liberia (FSI 300,8) 28. Seychelles (FSI 293,4) 29. Brazil (FSI 283,9) 30. Uruguay (FSI 277,4) 31. Saudi Arabia (FSI 274,2) 32. India (FSI 254,5) 33. Liechtenstein (FSI 240,9) 34. Isle of Man (FSI 237,2) 35. Bahamas (FSI 226,8] 36. South Africa (FSI 209,7) 37. Philippines (FSI 206,6) 38. Israel (FSI 205,9] 39. Netherlands (FSI 204,9) 40. Belgium (FSI 199,2) 41. Cyprus (FSI 198,9) 42. Dominican Republic (FSI 193,7) 43. France (FSI 190,9) 44. Australia (FSI 168,1) 45. Vanuatu (FSI 164,9) 46. Costa Rica (FSI 157,6) 47. Ireland (FSI 155.5) 48. New Zealand (FSI 151,4) 49. Gibraltar (FSI 147,8) 50. Norway (FSI 142,7) 51. Guatemala (FSI 142,7) 52. Belize (FSI 129,8) 53. Latvia (FSI 128,1) 54. Italy (FSI 118,9) 55. Aruba (FSI 113,3) 56. Spain (FSI 111,3) 57. Ghana (FSI 109,9) 58. Curacao (FSI 106,4) 59. US Virgin Islands (FSI 102,8) 60. Botswana (FSI 98,9) 61. Anguilla (FSI 96,7) 62. St Vincent and the Grenadines (FSI 85,1) 63. Turks & Caicos Islands (FSI 81,8) 64. Malta (FSI 78,0) 65. St Lucia (FSI 66,8) 66. Denmark (FSI 63,1] 67. Antigua and Barbuda (FSI 60,4) 68. San Marino (FSI 59,5) 69. Portugal (Madeira) (FSI 57.9) 70. Grenada (FSI 55,7) 71. Sweden (FSI 55,7) 72. Hungary (FSI 54,6) 73. Brunei (FSI 50,6) 74. Andorra (FSI 43,3) 75. Monaco (FSI 38,8) 76. Samoa (FSI 31,0) 77. Dominica (FSI 26,9) 78. Cook Islands (FSI 25,2) 79. Maldives (FSI 21,0) 80. St Kitts and Nevis (FSI 18,4) 81. Nauru (FSI 0,0) 82. Montserrat (FSI 0,0) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
R K Posted February 14, 2015 Share Posted February 14, 2015 (edited) http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-31470627 Ex-HSBC chairman Lord Green resigns from banking body Former HSBC chairman Lord Green has resigned as chairman of the advisory council for banking industry body, The City UK. The BBC understands it was Lord Green's decision to step down due to the ongoing media interest in him. Lord Green was HSBC chairman from 2003 to 2010, during which time it has been claimed the bank's Swiss private arm helped clients to avoid or evade tax. Lord Green has not commented on the claims, made in a BBC Panorama report. Chairman of The City UK's board, Sir Gerry Grimstone, said: "Stephen Green is a man of great personal integrity who has given huge service to his country and the City. "He doesn't want to damage the effectiveness of The City UK in promoting good governance and doing the right thing, so has decided to step aside from chairing our advisory council. This is entirely his own decision." hell just remain a Tory minister sitting in the Lords. Edited February 14, 2015 by R K Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
The Eagle Posted February 14, 2015 Share Posted February 14, 2015 (edited) The subject of this thread is very misleading, it should be: British Bank Helped Clients Dodge Taxes And Hide Millions or HSBC Helped Clients Dodge Taxes And Hide Millions can the OP (tyres) or a mod please correct it? Edited February 14, 2015 by The Eagle Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
R K Posted February 15, 2015 Share Posted February 15, 2015 (edited) Curious timing........... http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-31475945 Boris Johnson 'intends to renounce US citizenship He told the Sunday Times that his citizenship was "an accident of birth that has left me with this thing. I've got to find a way of sorting it out". The Mayor of London, who was born in New York, has in the past been forced to pay US tax because of his American citizenship. He has just completed a six-day tour of cities in the US. Mr Johnson said he would approach US ambassador Matthew Barzun to explore what steps he had to take to give up his American nationality. His passport was renewed in November 2012 but he had previously stated that he would give it up after being told in 2006 that, as a native born American, he could only use a US passport to travel in that country, and not his British one. "The reason I'm thinking I probably will want to make a change is that my commitment is, and always has been, to Britain," he said. In January he settled a US tax bill he had previously described as "absolutely outrageous". Mr Johnson had faced a demand from the US authorities to pay capital gains tax on profits from the sale of his house in north London. American law requires all citizens to pay US taxes even if they live abroad Edited February 15, 2015 by R K Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
TheCountOfNowhere Posted February 15, 2015 Share Posted February 15, 2015 The third story in a week about bankers, with no comments allowed: "HSBC Issues Apology Over Banking Standards2http://news.sky.com/story/1427764/hsbc-issues-apology-over-banking-standards I wonder why. I dont want an apology, I want the fraudsters locked up for the next 50 years. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
tyres Posted February 16, 2015 Author Share Posted February 16, 2015 Why don't tax dodgers ever go to jail? HSBC has been caught helping some of the richest people in Britain dodge hundreds of millions in tax. [1] The scandal has been snowballing for a week now - but the bankers still haven’t been brought to justice. [2]Politicians have spent the last week slinging insults at each other instead of tackling the problem. But the story isn’t going away, so a huge petition now will pile the pressure on the government to prosecute the bankers and tax dodgers involved. Things are moving fast, so we’ve only got 48 hours to make this petition huge before it’s delivered straight to the government on Wednesday. Click here to add your name: https://secure.38degrees.org.uk/prosecute-hsbc These taxes could have helped pay for our NHS or schools. It's just not fair that while the rest of us pay our fair share to keep the country going, HSBC and their wealthy clients are allowed to get away with breaking the law. This time, we’ve had enough of the rich playing by different rules. Public anger is at breaking point. If we can force the government to prosecute these tax dodgers, we can set the bar for them to fix our unfair tax system for good. Politicians, bankers and tax dodgers have had a tough week. [3] They’re desperate for this story to go away - so now’s the time to turn up the heat instead. 90,000 of us have already demanded that these bankers and tax dodgers are brought to justice. Can you add your name before it’s handed in on Wednesday? https://secure.38degrees.org.uk/prosecute-hsbc Thanks for being involved, Amy, Bex, Laura, Nat, Maddy and the 38 Degrees team Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
tyres Posted February 20, 2015 Author Share Posted February 20, 2015 George Osborne breaks silence on HSBC scandal: "It's not my job to catch tax dodgers" After nearly two weeks of silence from George Osborne, the Chancellor today answered questions about the HSBC tax dodging scandal Chancellor George Osborne finally broke his silence on the HSBC revelations today - but claimed catching tax dodgers was not his job. Mr Osborne has been dubbed the “Submarine Chancellor” by Labour after his failure to put his head above water and answer key questions about the scandal. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
byron78 Posted February 20, 2015 Share Posted February 20, 2015 Classic smoke and mirrors from Osborne. Of course it's not his job to catch tax dodgers. But it is his job to try and close loopholes to stop the rich/corporations ducking out of tax and forcing the rest of us to pick up the bill. Problem is he's the rich so he's not going to do that is he? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
davidg Posted February 20, 2015 Share Posted February 20, 2015 But it is his job to try and close loopholes to stop the rich/corporations ducking out of tax and forcing the rest of us to pick up the bill. Problem is he's the rich so he's not going to do that is he? every budget they seem to close more loopholes. The film investments scam introduced by New Labour has been ruled unlawful by the high court under general tax avoidance legislation. See GAAR introduced by Osbourne https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/tax-avoidance-general-anti-abuse-rules Brown doubled the tax code introducing hundreds of loopholes such as the film scam used by luvvies to hide their dosh. No doubt HMRC and the government could do more but simplifying tax legislation would be a useful start point. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.