Banks bailing out their own SIVs are practically ensuring their own sudden collapse when (not if) the first significant fire sale of mortgage securities happens.
This is 100% correct, guaranteed.
http://www.iht.com/articles/2007/12/03/business/siv.php
WestLB to guarantee $25 billion in liquidity to five SIVs
Published: December 3, 2007
FRANKFURT: The German bank WestLB said Monday that it would guarantee full liquidity to several of its investment vehicles that had put money into asset-backed securities - a step meant to limit fallout from the subprime lending crisis in the United States.
WestLB, based in Düsseldorf and one of the regional German banks, or Landesbanken, has two major programs, known as Harrier Finance and Kestrel Funding, which borrow money by selling short-term commercial paper to investors. They then invest the proceeds in higher-yielding securities, including ones backed by U.S. mortgages.
WestLB also has three other similar investment vehicles, known as conduits. All five will have the option of drawing as much as €25 billion, or $36.6 billion, as the short-term paper comes due.
"This will ensure that there is no compelled liquidation of the assets in the SIVs," said Armin Kloss, a WestLB spokesman, referring to structured investment vehicles. "We are also convinced that the assets that Kestrel and Harrier have could be more highly valued, but that the market is not ready for that."
WestLB said in August that "less than 5 percent" of its investments were subprime-related, Kloss said. But trading in asset-backed securities has largely stopped, so a forced sale now would cost dearly.
Like other banks - and many politicians - WestLB is betting that the market will eventually recover.
Joaquín Almunia, the European Union commissioner for economic and monetary affairs, warned Monday against new rules aimed at ameliorating the crisis. Any regulatory response to the crisis must be "considered and measured," he said.
"It is too early to reach firm conclusions on what has gone wrong in risk management in the financial sector and whether regulatory initiatives are needed," Almunia said in Brussels.
Structured investment vehicles are at the heart of the financial crisis unleashed by the deteriorating U.S. mortgage market. Questions about the losses from bad SIV investments have shaken credit markets, and pushed up short-term interest rates as banks hoard liquidity to guard against surprise losses.
HSH Nordbank, based in Hamburg, is taking a similar step that of WestLB, covering all of the €3.3 billion that its vehicle, called Carrera Capital, has issued. The step has helped secure its stable credit ratings with Moody's Investor Service and Standard & Poor's.
"What we're trying to do is avoid a write-down," Reinhard Schmid, an HSH Nordbank spokesman, said. "We can do that with liquidity."
Two German banks needed an outside rescue in August when speculation in subprime-related securities via the vehicles went badly awry. But those problems far outstripped what much more stable banks like WestLB and HSH Nordbank are facing. IKB Deutsche Industriebank and SachsenLB set up funds that were triple or quintuple the size of their capital on hand.
The British bank HSBC said last week that it would spend $35 billion to bring two vehicles it ran directly onto its books, effectively turning the bank into their guarantor of liquidity.
A similar principle lies being the so-called "SuperSIV" - officially known as the Master Liquidity Enhancement Conduit - that Citigroup, the largest sponsor of such vehicles in the world, has proposed. Together with Bank of America and JPMorgan Chase, Citigroup is proposing that $80 billion be devoted to buying up mortgage-backed securities and holding them until the market relaxes.
The banks are aiming to have the fund operational by early next year.
