Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Black Swans
House Price Crash forum > House Prices > Market psychology
lamina
Has anyone read "The Black Swan", by Nassim Taleb. This is about the impact of highly improbable events on life.

This seems to be entirely appropriate in the frenetic investing in property.

It worries me that many people here are putting all their eggs in the property basket - some are planning on using rising property prices to fund their retirement in 40 years time - it might be a good idea but who knows? We like to think, even though the past provides plenty of counter examples, that tomorrow wilbe much the same as today which was barely different from yesterday.
He gives an example of a casino in Las Vegas which spends a fortune on the prevention of cheating using security cameras etc etc. The losses the casino suffered from using this were 1000 times less than the unpredictable events which they occasionally suffered - a law suit when a tiger bit a performer, the kidnap of the owners daughter etc..

I could write more but will await any response. rolleyes.gif

Regards

Richard
LargelyIgnorant
The author was interviewed on Puplava's radio show on financialsense.com a while ago. It sounds interesting, but does is say much more than 'completely unexpected events happen'?

Isn't the trouble with black swan events is that they can't really be predicted or timed?
VeryMeanReversion
QUOTE(lamina @ Jun 6 2007, 05:41 PM) *
Has anyone read "The Black Swan", by Nassim Taleb. This is about the impact of highly improbable events on life.


Reading it now, I liked his earlier book.

VMR.
mikelivingstone
QUOTE (VeryMeanReversion @ Jul 19 2007, 11:45 AM) *
Reading it now, I liked his earlier book.

VMR.




I have read both Fooled by Randomness and The Black Swan. Both very interesting and thoughful, though Fooled by Randomness was an easier read and perhaps had more entertaining story telling and examples of overblown egos blowing up.
pepsi
I'm just finishing Black Swan now. I'm impressed that he managed to predict that the "normal distribution curve" applied to the market cause another disaster. I think the "Credit Crunch" caused by just that (i.e. "top-slicing") came along pretty quickly.

I keeping Fooled by Randomness for my holiday.
pepsi
QUOTE (lamina @ Jun 6 2007, 05:41 PM) *
...
It worries me that many people here are putting all their eggs in the property basket - some are planning on using rising property prices to fund their retirement in 40 years time - it might be a good idea but who knows?


I think you will find that the people "here" (i.e. this message board) are absolutely not the people who are doing this! I know people who think like this, but they are not on this site!
Furby
Enjoyed Black Swan immensely and has given me some ideas of my own in terms of future investment direction.

F
gilf
QUOTE (LargelyIgnorant @ Jun 14 2007, 09:49 PM) *
The author was interviewed on Puplava's radio show on financialsense.com a while ago. It sounds interesting, but does is say much more than 'completely unexpected events happen'?

Isn't the trouble with black swan events is that they can't really be predicted or timed?


Yeah pretty much.

While started off well it soon got very very tedious for me. He often says if your not interested in this aspect skip the next chapter, but if you did that the book would have been totally pointless. As you say the whole point of a Black Swan is it is totally unexpected and therefore there is nothing that can be done about them.

Never judge a book by it's cover but.... had it explored actual Black Swan events in more detail as it seemed to suggest it would, why they were Black Swans the effects etc it might have been a better read. The book basically looks at why things are unpredictable and goes into great detail about why they are wrong, to be fair he can't offer up much of an alternative as there isn't really one.


DrGUID
Reading it at the moment. I've had 8 black swans in my life this decade, only 2 in the 90's. The world is getting more volatile.

I have a black swan to thank for my current career. I spent 6 years training to be a scientist, but couldn't find a job afterwards. I spent 2 weeks reading a JavaScript for Dummies book, and ended up with a lucrative career in IT.

Another black swan - the dot com boom/collapse allowed me to experience a 3rd black swan - accidentally starting my own business (which is still going strong).

blink.gif
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.