Surely an end to a stamp duty 'holiday' can only serve FTBs better?
Assume a house value of £160k. 25 % deposit required = £40k.
Now, stamp duty needs paying upfront - i.e. out of the money to hand that could otherwise be used as a deposit. So of the £40k pot, you need to subtract 1.6k, leaving £38.4k available for deposit.
If, as we believe, house prices are mainly a function of available credit, and assuming banks are requiring a LTV of 25% at least for a decent mortgage rate, then the max you could now borrow would be 4 x £38.4k = £153.6. i.e. all other things being equal a seller would have to reduce their price by £6.4k.
Furthermore, if you assume that over a 25 yr mortgage you're roughly paying the bank a total of 2x the money you're borrowing, that's a total lifetime saving of ~ £12k!
Obviously, the real world is not so clean cut but you can see that kicking this 'aid' to FTBs away can only diminish the amount they can spend. How much bank pleading can we expect to 'reinstate' this support?
Am i pointing out the bleedin' obvious or have i missed something bleedin' obvious?!
Thoughts, Comments?!